ROBERT PARKER “The Wine Advocate”
- Carmignano DOCG “Riserva Elzana” 2004 – Rating: 92
- Carmignano DOCG “Le Vigne Alte Montalbiolo” 2004 – Rating: 92
- Carmignano DOCG “Montefortini” 2005 – Rating: 90
- Rosato di Toscana 2007 – Rating: 89
- Barco Reale di Carmignano DOC 2006 – Rating: 88
- Trebbiano di Toscana 2007 – Rating: 85
I VINI D’ITALIA 2008 (L’ESPRESSO)
- Carmignano DOCG “Riserva Elzana” 2004: “I vini dell’eccellenza” (wines of excellence) award, Rating 18/20
I VINI D’ITALIA 2009 (L’ESPRESSO)
- Carmignano DOCG “Riserva Le Vigne Alte Montalbiolo” 2005 – Rating: 16/20
- Carmignano DOCG “Monfefortini” 2006 – Rating: 15/20
- Barco Reale di Carmignano DOC 2007 – Rating: 14/20
DUEMILA VINI 2009 (Guide of A.I.S. Association of Italian Sommeliers)
- Carmignano DOCG “Riserva Elzana” 2004 – Rating: 4 grape clusters (the maximum rating is 5 grape clusters)
- Carmignano DOCG “Riserva Le Vigne Alte Montalbiolo” 2005 – Rating: 4 grape clusters
- Vin Santo di Carmignano DOC 2001 - Rating: 4 grape clusters
- Carmignano DOCG “S. Cristina in Pilli” 2006 – Rating: 3 grape clusters
- Carmignano DOCG “Monfefortini” 2006 – Rating: 3 grape clusters
- Barco Reale di Carmignano DOC 2007 – Rating: 3 grape clusters
VINI D’ITALIA 2009 (GAMBERO ROSSO)
- Carmignano DOCG “Riserva Elzana” 2005 – Rating: 2 red glasses (wines considered from very good to excellent and that were selected for the final tastings for the award of “tre bicchieri” (3 glasses, the highest rating)
- Carmignano DOCG “Riserva Le Vigne Alte Montalbiolo” 2005 – Rating: two black glasses (wines considered from very good to excellent in their respective categories)
I VINI DI VERONELLI 2009
- Carmignano DOCG “Riserva Elzana” 2005 – Rating: 3 stars, 93 points
- Carmignano DOCG “Riserva Le Vigne Alte Montalbiolo” 2005 - Rating: 3 stars, 92 points
- Carmignano DOCG “S. Cristina in Pilli” 2006 – Rating: 3 stars, 91 points
- Carmignano DOCG “Monfefortini” 2006 – Rating: 2 stars, 89 points
- Barco Reale di Carmignano DOC 2007 – Rating: 2 stars, 87 points
- Vin Santo di Carmignano DOC 2000 - Rating: 2 stars